new options
Every Weekend
WTF is a Fatty? That’s what we call our cookies. Fatties are thicc, packed with quality ingredients, and served fresh out of the oven.
Each weekend, we sling a new line-up of three flavors packed with nostalgia.
We work hard to come up with something fresh each week to keep you coming back for more.
life is better with
A little mystery
We keep our menu a secret until you order, deal with it.
Our flavors take inspiration from nostalgic childhood snacks, classic candies and sweets, as well as from viral treats you’ve only seen online.
The first weekend of every month, a new vegan cookie flavor takes the spotlight in the lineup. The rest of the time, go off menu: our secret Vegan Oreo Pudding Fatty is always waiting. We won’t tell if you won’t.
You never know what you’re going to get, but we can promise it’ll taste incredible.
WARM Cookies & cold ice cream delivered FAST
Fresh out of the oven warm cookies, delivered to your door.
WHAT’S BETTER THAN THAT?!
Our in-house delivery service, called Fatty Drops, is available to cities around Salem on Boston’s Northshore on select nights. It’s perfect for when you want a sweet treat but don’t want to brave the elements, or just want to make a chill night in even better.
Fatty Drops can be pre-ordered and scheduled to arrive when you want at your home, dorm, hotel, business or church.
Or you can place an order live when we’re open – we’ll instantly send one of our own drivers your way with a fresh box, seriously its insanely fast.
Where Do We Deliver Fatties?
Friday 5pm – 10pm
Salem & Beverly
Saturday 5pm – 10pm
Salem, Beverly, Danvers, Peabody, Swampscott, Marblehead, & Lynn
Sunday 5pm – 10pm
Salem
A COOKIE STORY
late one night after a nice dinner out, co-founders/owners Jen and Erik weren’t quite ready to call it a night. “You know what I could go for right now? – a cookie” In that moment they sadly realized that they were out of luck unless they were willing to bake their own. Jen and Erik spent the rest of the walk home talking about how they couldn’t be only ones who experience these late-night cookie cravings.
In that moment, Goodnight Fatty was born. We started popping up in coffee shops, breweries, and even a dark alleyway around Salem, MA with the mission of serving uniquely delicious cookies warm from the oven to crush late-night sweet cravings.
Today, Goodnight Fatty is still slingin’ a new line-up of Fatties every weekend. We now call the historic Andrew-Safford Carriage House our home. Formerly a frozen yogurt shop, the Carriage House is located across from the Salem Common, and is near many of Salem’s downtown restaurants and popular attractions.
